
The Peninsula New York
Best for travelers who want traditional, polished Midtown luxury, an indoor pool and a full-service Forbes-rated spa.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Peninsula New York is a landmark Beaux-Arts five-star hotel on Fifth Avenue with heritage service, an indoor pool, a Forbes-rated full-service spa and a rooftop bar; read this if you want classic Midtown luxury and formal dining. 1 Hotel Central Park is a five-star eco-luxury lifestyle hotel close to Central Park with nature-driven design and a living plant wall; read this if you prefer contemporary, sustainability-forward hotels near the park.
Updated · about 0.3 km apart

Best for travelers who want traditional, polished Midtown luxury, an indoor pool and a full-service Forbes-rated spa.

Best for travelers who prioritize eco-minded design, locally sourced food and a lifestyle-hotel feel steps from Central Park.
When The Peninsula New York wins: choose The Peninsula if you want landmark, full-service luxury in Midtown—multiple formal dining venues, a dedicated Forbes-rated spa, a glass-enclosed indoor pool with sun terrace and a rooftop bar with skyline views.
When 1 Hotel Central Park wins: pick 1 Hotel if you want contemporary, nature-forward interiors, strong sustainability practices (locally sourced food, no single-use plastic, living plant wall) and a Central Park–adjacent location with a lifestyle-hotel atmosphere.
Bottom line: both hotels put you within easy reach of Central Park and Midtown attractions. The Peninsula leans heritage and full-service pampering; 1 Hotel Central Park is more modern, eco-focused and casual. Your choice depends on whether you prefer classic luxury and spa facilities or a green, design-forward stay.
| Category | The Peninsula New York | 1 Hotel Central Park |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Landmark Beaux‑Arts, formal luxury and traditional service | Lifestyle eco-luxury with nature-driven design |
| Location | 700 Fifth Avenue at 55th Street — Midtown, about four blocks south of Central Park | 1414 Avenue of the Americas — steps from Central Park and mid‑Manhattan attractions |
| Size / rooms | Around 219–235 rooms across ~23 floors (major renovation completed 2024) | 229 guestrooms (room types include Alcove King, Studio, Park View, Park Suite, City Suite) |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome; children’s programs and family amenities available | |
| Pools | Glass-enclosed indoor pool with sun terrace; open 7:00 am–7:00 pm, complimentary for guests | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple venues: Clement (restaurant), Clement Bar, Gotham Lounge (afternoon tea), Pen Top rooftop bar | Jams Cafe (restaurant) plus a coffee shop/cafe and one bar/lounge |
| Spa & wellness | The Peninsula Spa — Forbes-rated, 11 treatment rooms, saunas/steam rooms, 24-hour fitness center | Not published |
| Signature features | Rooftop bar (Pen Top), legendary Afternoon Tea (Gotham Lounge), heritage building and landmark status | Living plant wall, strong sustainability policies (no single‑use plastic, composting, locally sourced food) |
| Accessibility & family | Wheelchair-accessible paths; family services, kids programs, pet-friendly with fee | Wheelchair-accessible features listed; children’s toys and pet/eco amenities noted |
| Business / events | Multiple meeting rooms and event spaces including Gramercy and Salon/rooftop spaces | Four meeting rooms and a 24-hour business center |
The Peninsula sits on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street in the heart of Midtown, close to shopping and museums.
Choose The Peninsula for immediate Fifth Avenue shopping access and classic Midtown sightseeing.
1 Hotel Central Park sits on Avenue of the Americas very close to Central Park and Midtown cultural sites.
Choose 1 Hotel for the shortest walk to Central Park and a green-focused Midtown location.
The Peninsula offers traditionally styled rooms and a range of suites with refined finishes.
The Peninsula is for travelers who want classic, formally appointed rooms and full-suite choices.
1 Hotel Central Park's guestrooms emphasize modern, eco-focused materials and park or city views.
1 Hotel suits guests who prefer contemporary rooms with sustainability-minded details and park views.
The Peninsula offers multiple formal dining and bar options with set service hours and specialties.
Pick The Peninsula if you want formal dining options, classic afternoon tea and a rooftop cocktail scene.
1 Hotel Central Park follows a lifestyle approach with one main restaurant and café options.
Choose 1 Hotel for relaxed, sustainably minded dining and a cafe-style food program.
The Peninsula's signature amenity is its glass-enclosed indoor pool and upper‑floor sun terrace.
The Peninsula is the obvious choice when an on-site indoor pool and terrace matter.
1 Hotel centralizes its identity around sustainability and visible nature-focused design elements.
Choose 1 Hotel for eco-conscious amenities and visible green design rather than an on-site pool focus.
The Peninsula combines a Forbes-rated full-service spa with a rooftop bar for evening drinks.
Go to The Peninsula for a comprehensive spa program plus a traditional rooftop evening venue.
1 Hotel focuses on wellness through sustainable practices, fitness access and a calm design aesthetic.
Pick 1 Hotel if you want straightforward fitness access and an eco-wellness atmosphere rather than a full spa and rooftop scene.

The Peninsula — Forbes-rated Peninsula Spa with 11 treatment rooms, saunas, steam rooms and a full range of treatments.

1 Hotel Central Park — living plant wall, extensive no-single-use-plastic policies and locally sourced food.

The Peninsula — Pen Top rooftop bar on the 23rd floor with outdoor terraces and skyline views.

1 Hotel Central Park — immediate Central Park access and a casual lifestyle-hotel layout ideal for park visits.
1 Hotel Central Park is steps from Central Park; The Peninsula is about four blocks south of the park.
The Peninsula New York has a glass-enclosed indoor pool open daily for guests. 1 Hotel Central Park's listing does not publish an on-site pool.
At The Peninsula New York, outside visitors who book a minimum of two hours of spa services receive full access to the pool, sun terrace and fitness center. 1 Hotel Central Park’s spa availability for non-guests is not published.
Yes. Both properties welcome guests of all ages; The Peninsula has dedicated children’s programs and family amenities.
Explore how The Peninsula New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·