
The Peninsula New York
Best for travelers who want a landmark Fifth Avenue address, a large Forbes-rated spa, family facilities, and a classic New York hotel experience.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Peninsula New York is a landmark Beaux‑Arts luxury hotel on Fifth Avenue with a focus on refined American dining, a full spa, and family-friendly amenities. Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York is a design‑led, crystal‑inspired luxury property in Midtown known for dramatic interiors and a boutique-house feel—read this if you're choosing between classic Beaux‑Arts refinement with family amenities (Peninsula) and a glamorous, design-forward Midtown stay (Baccarat).
Updated · about 0.2 miles (≈0.3 km) apart

Best for travelers who want a landmark Fifth Avenue address, a large Forbes-rated spa, family facilities, and a classic New York hotel experience.

Best for guests who prefer dramatic, design-forward interiors, a small-house luxury footprint, and proximity to MoMA and Rockefeller Center.
When The Peninsula New York wins: Choose The Peninsula if you value a larger, landmark property with multiple dining venues, an expansive Forbes-rated spa, an indoor pool with sun terrace included for guests, and family-friendly services (kids programs, babysitting).
When Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York wins: Pick Baccarat if you prefer a smaller, design-focused hotel with glamorous, crystal-influenced decor, direct proximity to MoMA and Rockefeller Center, and a boutique-luxury atmosphere.
Bottom line: Both hotels place you in prime Midtown Manhattan; go Peninsula for traditional, roomy hotel amenities and wellness options for families, and Baccarat for a distinctly designed, intimate luxury stay close to Midtown attractions.
| Category | The Peninsula New York | Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Beaux‑Arts landmark, traditional refined luxury | Glamorous, design-forward luxury with crystal motifs |
| Location (neighborhood) | Fifth Avenue at 55th Street — central to Fifth Ave shopping and near Central Park | West 53rd Street — steps from MoMA and Rockefeller Center |
| Size (guest rooms) | 235 guest rooms (23 floors) | 114 guestrooms |
| Building / age | 1905 Beaux‑Arts landmark building (landmarked) | Modern luxury property with design-led interiors |
| Pool | Glass‑enclosed indoor pool on upper floors; guest access included (7:00 am–7:00 pm) | Indoor pool (on‑site) |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple venues: Clement, Clement Bar, Gotham Lounge (afternoon tea), Pen Top rooftop | Grand Salon (French) plus bar/lounge and room service (limited hours) |
| Spa & wellness | The Peninsula Spa — Forbes Travel Guide Five‑Star, 11 treatment rooms, saunas and steam rooms | Full‑service spa with treatment rooms, sauna and steam room |
| Known for | Classic Fifth Avenue address, afternoon tea, rooftop skyline views, family programs | Baccarat brand aesthetic and crystal-inspired design drama, proximity to MoMA |
| Check-in / check-out | Standard check-in from 3:00 PM; check-out by 12:00 PM | Check-in begins at 4:00 PM; check-out by 12:00 PM |
| Number of restaurants | 3 restaurants + 1 bar/rooftop | Number of restaurants - 1; Number of bars/lounges - 1 |
The Peninsula sits on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street, putting flagship shopping, Central Park, Broadway and MoMA a short walk away.
Choose The Peninsula for a landmark Fifth Avenue address and easy access to Midtown attractions.
Baccarat Hotel sits on West 53rd Street, a short walk to MoMA and Rockefeller Center in Midtown Manhattan.
Pick Baccarat for tight Midtown access to museums and Midtown attractions in a design-focused setting.
The Peninsula offers a broad room and suite roster across a landmark building with traditional design and modern amenities.
The Peninsula is a better fit if you want more room-type choices and the scale of a larger historic hotel.
Baccarat has a smaller collection of guestrooms and suites with design-led interiors and in-room tablets.
Baccarat suits travelers seeking a smaller, design-centric hotel with carefully styled rooms.
The Peninsula has several on‑site venues covering casual to formal dining, plus a rooftop bar.
Go Peninsula for more variety on property and a traditional Afternoon Tea option.
Baccarat centers food and drink around Grand Salon and a single bar/lounge with room service options.
Baccarat is best if you prefer a single, signature dining experience in a hotel with strong design identity.
The Peninsula’s glass‑enclosed indoor pool sits on the upper floors and is included for hotel guests.
If pool access and a rooftop sun terrace included for guests matter, The Peninsula has the clearer guest‑inclusive setup.
Baccarat provides an on‑site indoor pool as one of its recreational amenities.
Baccarat offers wellness amenities including an indoor pool, though the property is smaller and more boutique in scale.
The Peninsula emphasizes an extensive spa and 24‑hour fitness, plus a rooftop bar with skyline views.
Choose The Peninsula for a larger, more programmatic spa and round‑the‑clock fitness options plus rooftop nightlife.
Baccarat’s wellness offering includes a full‑service spa and fitness facilities, presented within a design‑driven setting.
Baccarat fits guests who want a boutique spa experience and quieter, design-focused evening venues.

The Peninsula New York — classic Fifth Avenue location near Central Park, flagship shops, and museums.

Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York — crystal-inspired interiors and a tightly focused Midtown presence.

The Peninsula — kids programs, family-friendly pool access, large Forbes-rated spa and 24-hour fitness center.

Baccarat — steps from MoMA and very close to Rockefeller Center for museum- and shopping-focused itineraries.
The Peninsula is more family‑oriented with kids programs (Peninsula Academy/Camp Peninsula), family‑friendly spa packages, and an indoor pool with no age restriction.
Baccarat is likely the better pick for a romantic, design‑led stay thanks to its glamorous interiors and intimate footprint.
Yes. Both properties list a full‑service spa and an indoor pool; The Peninsula’s spa is Forbes-rated and its glass‑enclosed pool has specified guest hours.
The Peninsula offers multiple venues (restaurant, bar, lounge, rooftop), while Baccarat has a signature restaurant (Grand Salon) and a bar/lounge.
Explore how The Peninsula New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·