
The Peninsula New York
Best for travelers who want a traditional, full-service luxury stay with an indoor pool and an extensive spa.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Peninsula New York is a landmark, classic luxury hotel on Fifth Avenue with a strong wellness focus and family-friendly services. The New York EDITION is a 5-star, stylish lifestyle hotel steps from Madison Square Park for travelers who prefer a trendier design-led stay.
Updated · about 1.6 km apart

Best for travelers who want a traditional, full-service luxury stay with an indoor pool and an extensive spa.

Best for guests seeking a trend-led luxury experience in a lively Flatiron/Madison Square Park neighborhood.
When The Peninsula New York wins: choose The Peninsula if you prioritize a classic Beaux-Arts landmark location on Fifth Avenue, a large Forbes-rated spa, a glass-enclosed indoor pool with complimentary guest access, and formal dining and afternoon-tea options.
When The New York EDITION wins: choose The New York EDITION if you want a modern lifestyle hotel near Madison Square Park with contemporary design, two bars/lounges, and a compact set of meeting spaces in a walkable Flatiron/Union Square area.
Bottom line: both are five-star Manhattan hotels in strong neighborhoods. Pick The Peninsula for traditional luxury, wellness, and Midtown shopping access; pick The New York EDITION for a trendier, design-forward stay close to Madison Square Park and Flatiron.
| Category | The Peninsula New York | The New York EDITION |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Classic Beaux‑Arts luxury, formal dining and wellness focus | Stylish lifestyle hotel with contemporary design sensibility |
| Location | 700 Fifth Avenue at 55th Street (Midtown, near Central Park and Fifth Avenue shopping) | 5 Madison Avenue (steps from Madison Square Park and Flatiron Building) |
| Size (rooms) | 235 guest rooms (across 23 floors) | 271 air-conditioned rooms |
| Building / era | 1905 Beaux‑Arts landmark building | Not published |
| Pools | Glass-enclosed indoor pool on the upper floors (guest access complimentary; 7:00 am–7:00 pm) | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Clement (restaurant), Clement Bar, Gotham Lounge (afternoon tea), Pen Top rooftop bar | The Clocktower (restaurant), 2 bars/lounges, 24-hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | The Peninsula Spa (Forbes-rated, 11 treatment rooms, saunas/steam rooms, 24‑hr fitness) | Spa services and onsite massages/facials available (details: supplier listing) |
| Meeting & event space | Multiple venues incl. Gramercy North & South; several meeting rooms and ballrooms (large capacities cited) | Conference space ~2100 sq ft and 5 meeting rooms |
| Accessibility & family policy | Welcomes all ages; children under 12 stay free; family programs available | |
| Notable nearby | Central Park, MoMA, Rockefeller Center, Fifth Avenue shopping | Madison Square Park, Flatiron Building, near Empire State Building |
The Peninsula sits on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street, within easy walking distance of Central Park and flagship stores.
Best for travelers who want Midtown shopping and Central Park access.
The New York EDITION is steps from Madison Square Park, placing you near the Flatiron Building and Union Square.
Best for guests who prefer the Flatiron and Madison Square Park area.
The Peninsula offers a range of classic rooms and suites across 235 rooms with detailed service touches.
Choose The Peninsula for traditional room categories and full-service in-room amenities.
The New York EDITION lists 271 air-conditioned rooms, from standard rooms to lofts and suites.
Choose The New York EDITION for a wide selection of contemporary room types and accessibility options.
The Peninsula provides multiple on-site dining venues covering formal meals, tea, and rooftop cocktails.
The Peninsula suits travelers who want several in-house dining and beverage options, including classic afternoon tea.
The New York EDITION features The Clocktower restaurant, two bars/lounges and 24-hour room service.
The EDITION focuses on a compact set of stylish dining and drinking venues for a design-led crowd.
The Peninsula emphasizes wellness with a glass-enclosed indoor pool and poolside dining.
Pick The Peninsula if a hotel indoor pool and poolside service matter to you.
The New York EDITION lists on-site spa services and massages but supplier listing does not specify a pool.
The EDITION focuses on lifestyle amenities and a compact spa offering; pool information is not published.
Wellness and formal nightlife both feature at The Peninsula via a full-service spa and a rooftop bar.
The Peninsula combines a robust spa and 24‑hour fitness with a polished evening rooftop bar.
The New York EDITION provides spa services and bars geared to a trendier crowd near Madison Square Park.
The EDITION is geared to guests who want a contemporary nightlife and spa experience without a published large spa footprint like The Peninsula.

The Peninsula — Forbes-rated Peninsula Spa, glass-enclosed indoor pool with complimentary guest access.

The New York EDITION — lifestyle-brand energy and contemporary rooms steps from Madison Square Park.

The Peninsula — on Fifth Avenue near MoMA, Rockefeller Center, and Central Park.

The New York EDITION — ~2100 sq ft conference space and five meeting rooms in the Flatiron/Madison Square Park area.
The Peninsula is highly family-friendly with programs for kids and a pool open to all ages; The New York EDITION is also all-ages but positions itself as a lifestyle hotel.
The Peninsula New York's official policy states it does not charge a resort fee. The New York EDITION listing shows a destination fee of USD 51.64 per night.
The Peninsula is on Fifth Avenue about four blocks south of Central Park; The New York EDITION is farther downtown near Madison Square Park.
The supplier listing for The New York EDITION lists spa services but does not publish a pool; The Peninsula explicitly publishes an indoor pool.
Explore how The Peninsula New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·