
The Peninsula New York
Best for travelers who want classic Midtown Fifth Avenue style, afternoon tea and a rooftop bar with skyline views.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Peninsula New York is a landmark Beaux-Arts luxury hotel on Fifth Avenue with classic Midtown character and family-friendly facilities; this guide is for travelers who want refined, central Fifth Avenue style and easy access to shopping, museums and Broadway. Mandarin Oriental, New York is a Columbus Circle high-rise luxury hotel with strong wellness credentials and skyline/park views; read on if floor-to-ceiling views of Central Park and a modern spa-focused stay are your priority.
Updated · about 1.0 km apart

Best for travelers who want classic Midtown Fifth Avenue style, afternoon tea and a rooftop bar with skyline views.

Best for guests who prioritize high-floor views over Central Park and a modern spa-and-wellness experience.
When The Peninsula New York wins: choose The Peninsula for iconic Fifth Avenue character, multiple classic dining venues (Gotham Lounge, Clement, Pen Top) and a landmark, family-friendly feel with an on-site indoor pool and a Forbes-rated Peninsula Spa.
When Mandarin Oriental, New York wins: choose Mandarin Oriental for dramatic high-rise panoramic views of Central Park and the Hudson, a well-regarded full-service spa, and a sleek, contemporary Columbus Circle address near Lincoln Center.
Bottom line: both are five-star luxury hotels within easy Manhattan reach; pick The Peninsula for traditional Fifth Avenue elegance, family amenities and Midtown shopping access, or Mandarin Oriental for skyline/park vistas and a vertical, spa-forward stay.
| Category | The Peninsula New York | Mandarin Oriental, New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Classic Beaux-Arts luxury, formal public spaces and traditional service | Contemporary high-rise luxury, modern rooms and dramatic views |
| Location | Fifth Avenue at 55th Street — immediate access to Fifth Avenue shopping and close to MoMA and Central Park | 80 Columbus Circle at 60th Street — steps from Columbus Circle and Central Park's perimeter; near Lincoln Center |
| Size (guest rooms) | 235 guest rooms (historic building, 23 floors) | 244 guestrooms |
| Audience / ages | All ages welcome; family programs and children stay free under 12 | All ages welcome (up to 2 children 12 and under stay free when using existing bedding) |
| Pool | Glass-enclosed indoor pool on upper floors; complimentary for guests (7:00 am–7:00 pm) | Indoor pool (number of pools: 1) listed on supplier amenities |
| Restaurants & bars | Clement (main), Clement Bar, Gotham Lounge (afternoon tea), Pen Top rooftop bar | MO Lounge plus 24-hour room service and 2 bars/lounges listed |
| Spa & wellness | The Peninsula Spa — Forbes Travel Guide Five-Star, 11 treatment rooms, sauna/steam facilities | Full-service spa with massages, body treatments, facials, sauna and fitness facilities |
| Known for | Landmark Fifth Avenue address, Afternoon Tea at Gotham Lounge, rooftop Pen Top | High-floor Central Park/Hudson views and a modern wellness focus |
| Rooftop / views | Pen Top rooftop bar on 23rd floor with Fifth Avenue skyline views | High-rise rooms and suites with Hudson River or Central Park views |
| Transport & nearby | Very close to 5th Ave/53rd St and multiple subway lines; immediate Midtown walking access | Steps from Columbus Circle transit hub; close to Lincoln Center and Central Park |
The Peninsula sits on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street, putting flagship shopping, MoMA and Broadway in easy walking range.
Choose The Peninsula if you want immediate Fifth Avenue shopping and classic Midtown access.
Mandarin Oriental occupies a Columbus Circle high-rise at 80 Columbus Circle, with easy access to Central Park and Lincoln Center.
Choose Mandarin Oriental for top-floor park and river views and quick access to Columbus Circle transit.
The Peninsula offers classic rooms and suites in a landmark Beaux-Arts building with refined, traditional finishes.
Pick The Peninsula for traditional decor and a historic New York hotel feel.
Mandarin Oriental’s rooms focus on modern comfort and range from Hudson View to Central Park View rooms and multiple suite options.
Pick Mandarin Oriental if skyline or park views from a high floor matter most.
The Peninsula’s dining lineup leans on classic New York traditions—afternoon tea, refined American dining and a rooftop bar.
Choose The Peninsula for traditional, sit-down luxury dining and a celebrated afternoon tea.
Mandarin Oriental lists MO Lounge and multiple bars; the hotel also offers 24-hour room service.
Choose Mandarin Oriental for modern lounge settings and in-room dining with a view.
The Peninsula provides a glass-enclosed indoor pool on its upper floors with complimentary guest access.
Families and swim-focused guests will appreciate The Peninsula’s accessible upper-floor pool and terrace.
Mandarin Oriental lists an indoor pool and a comprehensive health club as part of its wellness offerings.
Pick Mandarin Oriental for a modern wellness program paired with indoor pool access and fitness facilities.
The Peninsula’s Forbes-rated Peninsula Spa and rooftop bar create both daytime wellness and evening social options.
The Peninsula pairs an award-level spa with a classic rooftop evening scene.
Mandarin Oriental emphasizes spa and wellness within a contemporary high-rise setting, plus bars and lounges for evenings.
Mandarin Oriental is a strong pick for guests focused on spa treatments and high-floor evening views.

The Peninsula New York — located directly on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street, steps from flagship stores and MoMA.

Mandarin Oriental, New York — high-rise rooms with Central Park and Hudson River view options.

The Peninsula New York — Gotham Lounge’s Afternoon Tea and Clement’s refined American menu are signature offerings.

Mandarin Oriental, New York — contemporary spa services, fitness facilities and wellness programming.
The Peninsula New York — it offers kids programs (Peninsula Academy/Camp Peninsula), family-friendly amenities, and children under 12 stay free.
Mandarin Oriental, New York — the supplier listing includes Central Park View and Hudson River View room types and the hotel is known for high-rise vistas.
Yes. Both properties list a full-service spa and an indoor pool among their amenities; The Peninsula’s spa is Forbes-rated and its pool is a glass-enclosed upper-floor pool with set hours.
The Peninsula New York — it sits directly on Fifth Avenue and is a short walk from flagship stores and MoMA.
Explore how The Peninsula New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·