
The Peninsula New York
Best for wellness and modern in-house facilities—spa, glass-enclosed indoor pool and a rooftop bar with skyline views.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Peninsula New York is a landmark Beaux-Arts Fifth Avenue luxury hotel with a Forbes Five-Star spa, indoor pool and a rooftop bar—good for travelers who prioritize wellness, in-house amenities and skyline views. The St. Regis New York is an iconic Fifth Avenue grand luxury hotel known for its Gilded Age glamour and included butler service—read this if you want formal service and classic New York elegance.
Updated · about 0.1 km apart

Best for wellness and modern in-house facilities—spa, glass-enclosed indoor pool and a rooftop bar with skyline views.

Best for classic grand luxury and formal service—historic rooms, traditional Gilded Age style and included butler service.
When The Peninsula New York wins: pick The Peninsula if you want a strong wellness focus (a full-service Forbes-rated spa, an indoor pool with sun terrace, 24-hour fitness) and a rooftop bar with skyline views—all complimentary or available on property.
When The St. Regis New York wins: choose The St. Regis for formal, old‑world Fifth Avenue luxury and the signature butler service, plus a historic grand‑hotel atmosphere close to Rockefeller Center and high-end shopping.
Bottom line: both are Fifth Avenue landmarks within a very short walk of one another; pick The Peninsula for spa-and-amenity-forward stays and rooftop nightlife, and pick The St. Regis for traditional Gilded Age service and classic ballroom-style luxury.
| Category | The Peninsula New York | The St. Regis New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary wellness-forward refinement in a restored Beaux-Arts building | Gilded Age, grand Fifth Avenue formality with classic service |
| Location | 700 Fifth Avenue at 55th Street (midtown Fifth Avenue, steps from MoMA/Rockefeller) | |
| Size (guest rooms) | 235 guest rooms | 238 air-conditioned guestrooms |
| Building / age | Beaux‑Arts building (original 1905) — landmark with recent renovation | Historic grand Fifth Avenue hotel with classic public rooms |
| Pools | Glass-enclosed indoor pool on upper floors (open daily 7:00–19:00; guests have complimentary access) | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Clement (main restaurant), Clement Bar, Gotham Lounge (afternoon tea), Pen Top rooftop bar | 2 restaurants, 1 bar/lounge; in-room dining (limited hours) |
| Spa & wellness | The Peninsula Spa, Forbes Travel Guide Five‑Star; 11 treatment rooms, saunas/steam rooms, 24‑hour fitness center | Not published |
| Signature service | Peninsula Time (early check-in/late check-out for direct bookings), wellness amenities | Butler service included in many room types |
| Meetings & events | Multiple meeting rooms and event spaces (several ballrooms/terraces, Salon/Gramercy/Clement capacities available) | Conference space: 3,944 sq ft and 13 meeting rooms |
| Accessibility & family policy | All ages welcome; children under 12 stay free; family-friendly programs and kids’ activities available | |
The Peninsula sits on the southwest corner of Fifth Avenue and 55th Street, putting Fifth Avenue shops, MoMA and Rockefeller Center a short walk away.
Best for shoppers and museum-goers who want immediate Fifth Avenue access and quick Midtown walks.
The St. Regis sits on East 55th Street off Fifth Avenue, similarly central to Rockefeller Center and high-end shopping.
Best for travelers who want formal Fifth Avenue presence with easy access to Midtown landmarks.
The Peninsula offers 9 room types across 235 rooms, focused on modern amenities and wellness access.
Choose The Peninsula for modern rooms tied to spa/pool access and family-friendly policies.
The St. Regis lists many room and suite variants (including Butler Service in many categories) across 238 guestrooms.
Pick The St. Regis if you want rooms presented in traditional grand‑hotel style with included butler service in many categories.
The Peninsula provides several on-site dining outlets including a rooftop bar and a restaurant serving refined American cuisine.
The Peninsula is strong for daytime dining, afternoon tea and evening rooftop drinks.
The St. Regis offers two restaurants and a bar/lounge, plus limited-hour room service and formal dining options.
The St. Regis leans toward formal, classic dining experiences tied to traditional luxury service.
The Peninsula’s glass-enclosed indoor pool and rooftop terrace are central on-site features.
The Peninsula’s pool + rooftop bar combination is a defining amenity set for on-site relaxation and nightlife.
The St. Regis is best known for its formal service and historic public rooms rather than a notable pool or rooftop.
If you prioritize butler service and historic ambience over on-site pool or rooftop amenities, the St. Regis fits that preference.
The Peninsula centers on wellness with a full-service Forbes-rated spa and 24-hour Technogym-equipped fitness center.
Choose The Peninsula for programmatic wellness, round‑the‑clock fitness and rooftop nightlife.
The St. Regis emphasizes classic indoor public rooms and a single bar/lounge rather than a large wellness program in the published listing.
The St. Regis is more about formal dining and service than a marketed modern wellness program in the available sources.

The Peninsula New York — glass-enclosed indoor pool, a Forbes-rated full-service spa and 24-hour fitness center.

The St. Regis New York — classic Gilded Age formality and included butler service in many room types.

The Peninsula New York — Pen Top rooftop bar and two terraces on the 23rd floor.

The St. Regis New York — large, formal meeting and event capacity with historic public rooms.
The Peninsula New York is explicitly family-friendly with kids programs, complimentary pool access for guests and children under 12 staying free; The St. Regis welcomes all ages but is more classically formal.
The St. Regis New York lists many room types with 'Butler Service Included' in the room name. The Peninsula does not list included butler service.
The Peninsula New York has a glass-enclosed indoor pool and a Forbes-rated full-service spa. Pool and spa details for The St. Regis are not published in the supplier listing.
The Peninsula New York offers 'Peninsula Time' (complimentary early check-in/late check-out for direct bookings or via travel advisors when available). Check policies at booking for The St. Regis.
Explore how The Peninsula New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·