
The Peninsula New York
Best for shoppers and spa-focused travelers who want a refined Fifth Avenue address and classic hotel public spaces.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Peninsula New York is a landmark Beaux-Arts luxury hotel on Fifth Avenue with a full-service spa, rooftop bar and family-friendly amenities. Trump International Hotel & Tower New York is a Central Park–adjacent luxury tower at Columbus Circle known for tower views and Jean-Georges; read this if you’re deciding between Fifth Avenue heritage and a park-facing tower stay.
Updated · about 0.8 km apart

Best for shoppers and spa-focused travelers who want a refined Fifth Avenue address and classic hotel public spaces.

Best for travelers who prioritize Central Park/Columbus Circle location and larger tower rooms with park views.
When The Peninsula New York wins: Choose The Peninsula for Fifth Avenue shopping access, a Forbes-rated full-service spa on the upper floors, a signature afternoon tea at Gotham Lounge, and a rooftop bar with skyline views — a good pick if you want classic Midtown elegance and extensive on-site wellness.
When Trump International Hotel & Tower New York wins: Pick Trump International when proximity to Columbus Circle and Central Park views matter most, or when you want rooms in a tower format and dining at Jean-Georges; it’s a strong option for park-facing rooms and a recognizable Midtown tower address.
Bottom line: Both are five-star Midtown hotels with indoor pools, spas and easy Midtown access. Choose The Peninsula for Fifth Avenue location, a landmark building and a stronger spa/culinary identity; choose Trump International for Columbus Circle proximity, skyline/park views and a tower-hotel layout.
| Category | The Peninsula New York | Trump International Hotel & Tower New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Classic Beaux-Arts luxury with refined public rooms and Midtown formality | Contemporary luxury tower focused on park-facing rooms and views |
| Location | 700 Fifth Avenue at 55th St — immediate Fifth Avenue shopping, near Central Park | 1 Central Park W — on Columbus Circle, steps from Central Park |
| Size / rooms | 235 guest rooms across a landmark building | 176 guestrooms in a tower configuration |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome; family programs and kids’ amenities | |
| Pools | Glass-enclosed indoor pool on upper floors; complimentary for guests | Indoor pool (number of pools: 1 listed); guest access |
| Restaurants & bars | Clement, Clement Bar, Gotham Lounge (Afternoon Tea), Pen Top rooftop | 2 restaurants including Jean-Georges and a bar/lounge; room service |
| Spa & wellness | The Peninsula Spa (Forbes-rated), multiple treatment rooms, sauna/steam | Full-service spa with treatment rooms, sauna and steam facilities |
| Known for | Fifth Avenue heritage, afternoon tea and a celebrated spa | Columbus Circle tower views and Jean-Georges dining |
| Accessibility & family features | Kids programs, family pool access, pet-friendly with fee | Family-friendly hotel, accessible facilities and services |
| Transport & nearby | Steps from Fifth Avenue shopping, MoMA and Rockefeller Center | Steps from Central Park and Lincoln Center; near Broadway/theaters |
The Peninsula sits on the corner of Fifth Avenue and 55th Street, placing you in the heart of Midtown shopping and a short walk to Central Park.
Best if you want a classic Fifth Avenue address with easy museum, shop and Midtown access.
Trump International Hotel & Tower occupies a tower at Columbus Circle, immediately adjacent to Central Park and its paths.
Best if proximity to Central Park and Columbus Circle transit/connections matter most.
The Peninsula’s rooms are in a remodeled early-20th-century landmark building with a mix of classic and renovated rooms and suites.
Choose The Peninsula if you prefer landmark architecture and classic Midtown room layouts.
Trump International’s 176 guestrooms are arranged in a tower format, which produces many rooms with park or skyline views.
Choose Trump International for tower rooms and clearer chances at Central Park or city views.
The Peninsula concentrates on refined American dining across several distinct venues including a rooftop bar and a renowned afternoon tea.
The Peninsula is strong for daytime refinement, tea and a rooftop evening scene.
Trump International offers on-site dining led by Jean-Georges alongside a hotel bar and limited room service hours.
Trump International is best if Jean-Georges or a park-view dining location is a priority.
The Peninsula’s glass-enclosed indoor pool and sun terrace are located on the upper floors and are complimentary for hotel guests.
The Peninsula is ideal for guests who value an upper-floor, hotel-guest-accessible indoor pool integrated with the spa.
Trump International lists an indoor pool among its recreational amenities alongside a 24‑hour health club and sauna.
Trump International gives you a standard set of wellness amenities including an indoor pool and 24-hour gym.
The Peninsula emphasizes a large, Forbes-rated spa and a 24-hour Technogym-equipped fitness center.
Pick The Peninsula when a top-tier spa and around-the-clock fitness are deciding factors.
Trump International offers a full-service spa, a 24-hour health club, and an on-site bar for post-sightseeing drinks.
Trump International covers the essential spa and fitness needs while emphasizing park views in guest rooms and public spaces.

The Peninsula sits directly on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street, steps from flagship stores and MoMA.

Trump International is located at Columbus Circle with easy access to Central Park and many tower rooms with park views.

The Peninsula Spa is Forbes-rated with multiple treatment rooms, sauna/steam facilities and a large wellness footprint.

Trump International lists Jean-Georges among its on-site restaurants, a noted dining draw.
The Peninsula New York is on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street and is the closer choice for flagship shopping and nearby museums.
Trump International Hotel & Tower New York sits at Columbus Circle and places you immediately adjacent to Central Park.
Yes. Both properties have indoor pools and full-service spas; The Peninsula’s spa has a larger, Forbes-rated facility on upper floors.
Neither property is adults-only; both welcome guests of all ages and offer family-friendly services.
Explore how The Peninsula New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·