
The Peninsula New York
Best for shoppers and first-time New York visitors who want immediate access to Fifth Avenue, Midtown museums, and a skyline rooftop experience.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Peninsula New York is a landmark Beaux-Arts luxury hotel on Fifth Avenue with a rooftop bar and a glass-enclosed indoor pool—best for travelers who want Midtown shopping, museums, and skyline views. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel is an Upper East Side luxury institution known for residential elegance, Bemelman's Bar and Café Carlyle—best for quieter, classic New York stays and art- or music-focused evenings.
Updated · about 2.0 km apart

Best for shoppers and first-time New York visitors who want immediate access to Fifth Avenue, Midtown museums, and a skyline rooftop experience.
Best for travelers who prefer a low-key, residential address with old‑New York service, discreet luxury, and late-night live music or cabaret.
When The Peninsula New York wins: choose The Peninsula if you want to be in the heart of Midtown with quick access to Fifth Avenue shopping, MoMA and Broadway, plus a prominent rooftop bar and an upper‑floor indoor pool and large spa.
When The Carlyle wins: choose The Carlyle for a more residential, Upper East Side feel, historic rooms and suites, and for those who prioritize legendary bars and a music/cabaret experience (Bemelman's Bar, Café Carlyle) near the Met and Central Park.
Bottom line: both are classic, five‑star New York hotels; pick The Peninsula for central Midtown energy, rooftop cocktails and larger spa/pool facilities, or pick The Carlyle for old‑school Upper East Side elegance, quieter streets and notable evening entertainment.
| Category | The Peninsula New York | The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Beaux‑Arts landmark, Midtown energy and polished service | Classic Upper East Side luxury institution, residential elegance |
| Location | 700 Fifth Avenue at 55th Street (Midtown, shopping & museums nearby) | 35 E 76th St (Upper East Side, close to Central Park and the Met) |
| Size (guest rooms) | 235 guest rooms | 188 guestrooms |
| Building / era | 1905 Beaux‑Arts landmark building | Art Deco / historic Upper East Side hotel |
| Pool | Glass‑enclosed indoor pool on upper floors, guest access included | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Clement, Clement Bar, Gotham Lounge (afternoon tea) and Pen Top rooftop | Bemelman's Bar, 2 restaurants (including Café Carlyle) and a hotel bar/lounge |
| Spa & wellness | The Peninsula Spa (Forbes Five‑Star), 11 treatment rooms, fitness center open 24 hours | Full‑service spa and health club listed among amenities |
| Known for | Rooftop skyline views, afternoon tea at Gotham Lounge, large spa | Café Carlyle, Bemelman's Bar, discreet celebrity history |
| Access to landmarks | Steps from Fifth Avenue shopping, MoMA, Rockefeller Center and Broadway | Within a 10‑minute walk of Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art |
| Family policy | All ages welcome; children's programs and family pool access | |
The Peninsula sits on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street, putting flagship shopping, MoMA and Rockefeller Center an easy walk away.
Choose The Peninsula if you want Midtown sights and shopping on your doorstep.
The Carlyle is on East 76th Street, a quiet residential stretch a few blocks from Central Park and the Met.
Choose The Carlyle for a more residential, museum‑centric location near Central Park.
The Peninsula offers 235 rooms and a range of suites with modern amenities and classic decor in a restored Beaux‑Arts building.
Pick The Peninsula for larger room inventory and direct booking perks.
The Carlyle has 188 guestrooms and a long roster of room categories and Rosewood suites with a classic, residential feel.
Pick The Carlyle if you want classic Upper East Side rooms and a strong suite selection with traditional service.
The Peninsula emphasizes Midtown dining and a rooftop bar plus the famous Gotham Lounge afternoon tea.
Choose The Peninsula for a mix of formal dining, iconic afternoon tea and rooftop skyline drinks.
The Carlyle is best known for evening entertainment and classic New York bars and cafes.
Choose The Carlyle for late‑night drinks, live music and a classic New York nightlife experience.
The Peninsula’s glass‑enclosed indoor pool and large, multi‑level Peninsula Spa are major on‑site features.
The Peninsula is the stronger pick for on‑site spa and a proper indoor pool experience.
The Carlyle’s signature draw is its evening programming—Bemelman's Bar and Café Carlyle—rather than a highlighted large pool complex.
The Carlyle is the better choice if evening music, bars and a quieter, classic New York atmosphere are your priority.
Wellness at The Peninsula centers on a large spa plus a rooftop venue for evening drinks.
The Peninsula combines substantial spa/wellness facilities with a lively rooftop nightlife option.
The Carlyle’s nightlife is intimate and performance‑based, anchored by Bemelman's Bar and Café Carlyle.
Choose The Carlyle for hotel‑centered evening entertainment and a quieter, more intimate nightlife scene.

The Peninsula New York — immediate access to Fifth Avenue, MoMA, Rockefeller Center and Broadway.
The Carlyle — Bemelman's Bar and Café Carlyle are destination venues for late‑night cocktails and performances.

The Peninsula New York — large Peninsula Spa, glass‑enclosed upper‑floor pool and 24‑hour fitness center.
The Carlyle — quieter, elegant UES address close to Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
The Peninsula New York — it’s on Fifth Avenue near MoMA, Rockefeller Center and Broadway, making Midtown sightseeing convenient.
The Carlyle — Bemelman's Bar and Café Carlyle are well known for cocktails and live music/cabaret nights.
No — both hotels welcome guests of all ages.
Non‑hotel visitors who book at least two hours of spa treatment can get full access to the Peninsula’s pool, sun terrace and fitness center.
Explore how The Peninsula New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·