
The Peninsula New York
Best for travelers who want a central Midtown base, multiple on-site dining options, and a large full-service spa with an indoor pool.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Peninsula New York is a landmark Fifth Avenue luxury hotel with a large spa, indoor pool and multiple restaurants; read this if you want classic Midtown convenience and full-service wellness. The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel is an Upper East Side boutique luxury address near Central Park and the Met; read this if you prefer a quieter, residential neighborhood and a smaller hotel footprint.
Updated · about 1.6 km apart

Best for travelers who want a central Midtown base, multiple on-site dining options, and a large full-service spa with an indoor pool.

Best for travelers who prefer a quieter Upper East Side boutique hotel within easy walking distance of Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
When The Peninsula New York wins: choose The Peninsula for classic Fifth Avenue location, wider on-site dining and event options, a larger spa program and a glass-enclosed indoor pool included for guests.
When The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel wins: pick The Surrey for a smaller, residential-feel Upper East Side property that puts you steps from the Met and Madison Avenue and suits travelers who prefer boutique scale over Midtown bustle.
Bottom line: both are five-star luxury choices in Manhattan; The Peninsula is the fuller-service Midtown flagship with larger facilities, while The Surrey is the more intimate, museum-district boutique option.
| Category | The Peninsula New York | The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Formal, landmark Midtown luxury with broad facilities | Quiet, boutique Upper East Side luxury |
| Location | Fifth Avenue at 55th St (Midtown, near MoMA, Rockefeller Center) | 20 East 76th Street (Upper East Side, ~5-min walk to Central Park and the Met) |
| Size (rooms) | 219 guest rooms across 23 floors (historic Beaux-Arts building) | 100 guestrooms |
| Audience / ages | All ages welcome; family programs and kids’ offerings | |
| Pools / beach | Glass-enclosed indoor pool (upper floors), guest access included | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple venues: Clement (restaurant), Clement Bar, Gotham Lounge (afternoon tea), Pen Top (rooftop) | Casa Tua (Italian restaurant) + 1 bar/lounge; 24-hour room service available |
| Spa & wellness | The Peninsula Spa (Forbes-rated), 11 treatment rooms, saunas/steam rooms, 24-hour fitness center | Full-service spa and spa treatment room(s); fitness classes on site and 24-hour fitness facilities listed |
| Known for | Fifth Avenue landmark address, afternoon tea and rooftop Pen Top views | Revived boutique Upper East Side address, steps from Central Park and the Met |
| Parking & transfers | Secured valet parking (fee) and on-site electric car charging station | Covered and secured parking available; valet parking (surcharge) |
| Wi‑Fi & business | Complimentary Wi‑Fi included; several meeting/event rooms | |
The Peninsula sits on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street in Midtown, steps from flagship shopping and MoMA.
Choose The Peninsula for immediate Midtown access and sightseeing on foot.
The Surrey is on East 76th Street in the Upper East Side, a short walk to Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
Choose The Surrey to be near Central Park, the Met and a calmer neighborhood atmosphere.
The Peninsula offers a broad roster of room and suite categories in a historic Beaux‑Arts building.
The Peninsula is for travelers who want more room-type choices and traditional luxury hotel services.
The Surrey has about 100 guestrooms, positioned as a boutique Upper East Side hotel.
The Surrey suits travelers who prefer a smaller, upscale boutique inventory near museums.
The Peninsula provides several on-site dining and drinking venues across different atmospheres.
The Peninsula is better if you want more dining variety on-site, including a rooftop bar.
The Surrey highlights Italian dining with Casa Tua and offers one bar/lounge and 24-hour room service.
The Surrey is a good pick if you prefer a focused, neighborhood dining experience rather than multiple hotel venues.
The Peninsula’s signature amenity for many guests is its glass-enclosed indoor pool and multi-level spa complex.
The Peninsula is the clear choice if an indoor pool and larger spa complex matter to you.
The Surrey emphasizes boutique-scale services rather than large swimming facilities.
If a large hotel pool is a requirement, The Surrey’s listing does not publish one.
The Peninsula combines a large Forbes-rated spa with a rooftop bar and late-night options.
The Peninsula offers a broader in-house wellness and evening scene, including spa and rooftop nightlife.
The Surrey offers a full-service spa and a quieter Upper East Side evening scene focused on neighborhood dining.
The Surrey fits guests who want spa services plus a low-key neighborhood evening experience rather than hotel nightlife.

The Peninsula — larger Forbes-rated spa plus a glass-enclosed indoor pool and sun terrace included for guests.

The Surrey — Upper East Side location one block from Madison Ave, minutes on foot to Central Park and the Met.

The Peninsula — Clement, Gotham Lounge, Clement Bar and Pen Top rooftop give you different on-site dining moods.

The Surrey — smaller property with around 100 rooms and a focused Italian restaurant (Casa Tua).
The Surrey is closer — about a 5-minute walk to Central Park. The Peninsula is around four blocks south of the park in Midtown.
The Peninsula has a glass-enclosed indoor pool with guest access included. The Surrey’s supplier listing does not publish a pool.
No. Both properties welcome guests of all ages.
The Peninsula offers multiple on-site venues (restaurant, bar, lounge, rooftop). The Surrey has a single signature in-house restaurant (Casa Tua) and one bar/lounge.
Explore how The Peninsula New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·