
The Peninsula New York
Best for visitors who want a central Midtown address, a large full-service spa, and an indoor pool included for guests.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Peninsula New York is a landmark Fifth Avenue luxury hotel with a Forbes-rated full-service spa and an indoor pool; read this if you want Midtown shopping, refined dining, and a classic New York address. The Mark is a fashionable Upper East Side luxury hotel known for its Jacques Grange interiors and fashion-world visibility; read this if you want Upper East Side style, museum proximity, and bold design.
Updated · about 2.1 km apart

Best for visitors who want a central Midtown address, a large full-service spa, and an indoor pool included for guests.

Best for travelers seeking a stylish, fashion-forward Upper East Side stay with individually decorated rooms and museum proximity.
When The Peninsula New York wins: choose the Peninsula for a classic, centrally located Midtown base with a large Forbes-rated spa, a glass-enclosed indoor pool with complimentary guest access, and multiple dining venues that suit business, family, and tourists who want Fifth Avenue and Broadway within easy reach.
When The Mark wins: pick The Mark if you value Upper East Side style, individually decorated rooms, close access to the Met and Madison Avenue boutiques, and a hotel with strong fashion and pop-culture visibility.
Bottom line: both are high-end Manhattan hotels for discerning travelers; use The Peninsula for Midtown convenience plus spa and pool access, and The Mark for Upper East Side design, museum proximity, and a fashion-world personality.
| Category | The Peninsula New York | The Mark |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Classic Beaux-Arts Midtown luxury, refined public rooms and traditional service | Fashionable, bold Jacques Grange–styled Upper East Side luxury |
| Location | Fifth Avenue at 55th Street — Midtown, steps from Fifth Avenue shopping and near Central Park | 25 E 77th Street — Upper East Side, close to the Metropolitan Museum of Art and Madison Avenue |
| Size (rooms) | About 219 guest rooms (23 floors) | 152 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Guest age policy | All ages welcome; family programs and children's services available | |
| Pools | Glass-enclosed indoor pool on upper floors; guest access included (7:00 am–7:00 pm) | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple venues including Clement (main restaurant), Clement Bar, Gotham Lounge (Afternoon Tea), and Pen Top rooftop | Two restaurants and two bars/lounges; in-room dining and room service available (limited hours) |
| Spa & wellness | The Peninsula Spa — Forbes-rated, 11 treatment rooms, saunas and steam rooms, fitness center open 24 hours | Spa services on site (onsite massages listed); full spa facilities and signature treatments not detailed in supplier listing |
| Known for | Landmark Fifth Avenue address, refined American dining, rooftop Pen Top views and afternoon tea | Fashion-world pedigree, Jacques Grange interiors, proximity to the Met and Madison Avenue shopping |
| Typical guest | Shoppers, museumgoers, business and leisure travelers wanting a Midtown base with wellness amenities | Style-conscious travelers, museum visitors, guests wanting Upper East Side boutiques and a photogenic hotel |
| Parking & transport notes | Valet parking (fee) and an on-site electric car charging station; close to multiple subway lines | Valet parking (surcharge) listed; near Madison Avenue and close to Central Park / museums |
The Peninsula sits on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street, a Midtown address that places shopping, museums and Broadway within easy reach.
Choose the Peninsula if a central Midtown address and Fifth Avenue shopping matter most.
The Mark is on 25 E 77th Street in the Upper East Side, near the Metropolitan Museum of Art and Madison Avenue boutiques.
Choose The Mark for museum-focused trips and an Upper East Side neighborhood feel.
The Peninsula offers a range of traditional luxury rooms and suites across 23 floors in a landmark Beaux-Arts building.
The Peninsula is a solid choice for travelers who want classic luxury rooms with consistent service and family amenities.
The Mark's 152 guestrooms are individually decorated, reflecting a bold interior design approach.
The Mark suits travelers who want distinctive, design-forward rooms and larger suite options.
The Peninsula provides several dining venues covering refined American cuisine, afternoon tea, a mezzanine bar and a rooftop.
The Peninsula is for guests who expect formal dining choices, afternoon tea and a rooftop bar in Midtown.
The Mark lists two restaurants and two bars/lounges and has a notable on-property restaurant called The Mark Restaurant.
The Mark appeals to travelers who prioritize stylish dining within a fashion-oriented hotel environment.
The Peninsula features a glass-enclosed indoor pool and a large, Forbes-rated spa as core wellness amenities.
The Peninsula is the clear choice for guests who want an indoor pool and extensive spa facilities included with the stay.
The Mark lists spa services on site but does not publish a pool in the supplier listing.
If pool access is important, verify The Mark’s current on-site pool availability before booking.
The Peninsula offers an extensive spa program plus a rooftop bar that draws evening crowds.
The Peninsula blends robust spa services with a lively rooftop bar for evenings in Midtown.
The Mark focuses on stylish, intimate nightlife and design-forward public spaces rather than large-scale wellness facilities.
Choose The Mark for quieter, design-led evenings and boutique hotel nightlife; check spa details if wellness is a priority.

The Peninsula — a Forbes-rated full-service spa plus a guest-access indoor, glass-enclosed pool.

The Mark — steps from the Met and Madison Avenue shopping, with a fashion-world personality.

The Peninsula — Fifth Avenue address puts flagship stores, MoMA and Broadway within easy reach.

The Mark — known for Jacques Grange design touches and strong pop-culture/fashion visibility.
The Peninsula has well-documented children’s programs (Camp Peninsula / Peninsula Academy) and family-friendly pool access; The Mark accepts families but has fewer published family-specific programs.
The Peninsula has a glass-enclosed indoor pool with complimentary guest access; The Mark’s supplier listing does not publish an on-site pool.
The Mark is closer to the Metropolitan Museum of Art and Madison Avenue galleries; The Peninsula is a short taxi, subway or walk away but sits in Midtown.
Yes — The Peninsula is ideal for Fifth Avenue flagship shopping and Midtown retail; The Mark is ideal for Madison Avenue boutiques and Upper East Side designers.
Explore how The Peninsula New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·