
The Peninsula New York
Best for travelers who want classic Midtown addresses, Fifth Avenue shopping, and a landmark hotel experience with a glass‑enclosed indoor pool and a Forbes‑rated spa.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Peninsula New York is a landmark Beaux-Arts luxury hotel on Fifth Avenue that suits travelers who want classic Midtown addresses, formal dining, and an indoor pool and spa. The Ritz-Carlton New York, NoMad is a modern Ritz-Carlton tower in the NoMad neighborhood aimed at guests who prefer contemporary design, downtown views, and a recognized luxury brand.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart

Best for travelers who want classic Midtown addresses, Fifth Avenue shopping, and a landmark hotel experience with a glass‑enclosed indoor pool and a Forbes‑rated spa.

Best for guests who want a newer, downtown‑facing Ritz‑Carlton with modern rooms, club/club lounge options, and convenient access to Madison Square Park and Flatiron.
When The Peninsula New York wins: Choose The Peninsula if you want a landmark Fifth Avenue address, classic New York service, an indoor pool included for guests, and established dining options like Clement, Gotham Lounge (afternoon tea) and rooftop Pen Top. Its location is stronger for Midtown shopping, museums, and Central Park access.
When The Ritz‑Carlton New York, NoMad wins: Pick the NoMad Ritz‑Carlton if you prefer a more contemporary tower hotel with Ritz‑Carlton branding, downtown views, club rooms and suites with Club Lounge access, and proximity to Madison Square Park, the Flatiron District and Empire State Building.
Bottom line: Both are five‑star Manhattan luxury options; The Peninsula is the choice for traditional, Midtown, landmark hotel experiences with a guest pool and long‑standing dining venues, while The Ritz‑Carlton New York, NoMad is the better fit for travelers wanting a modern Ritz experience in NoMad and easy access to downtown neighborhoods.
| Category | The Peninsula New York | The Ritz-Carlton New York, NoMad |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Classic, formal Midtown Beaux‑Arts luxury | Contemporary, tower‑style modern luxury |
| Location | Fifth Avenue at 55th St — Midtown, close to Central Park, MoMA and Rockefeller Center | NoMad — near Madison Square Park, Flatiron and the Empire State Building |
| Size / rooms | 235 guest rooms across a landmark building | About 250 guestrooms |
| Age / building | Original 1905 Beaux‑Arts landmark, recently renovated | Newer modern tower (contemporary Ritz‑Carlton property) |
| Pools | Glass‑enclosed indoor pool on upper floors (guest access included) | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple venues — Clement (main restaurant), Clement Bar, Gotham Lounge (afternoon tea), Pen Top rooftop | Two restaurants and two bars, including Mediterranean option Zaytinya and 24‑hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | The Peninsula Spa (Forbes‑rated) with 11 treatment rooms, sauna and steam; 24‑hour Technogym fitness center | Full‑service spa on site with massages, body treatments and facials; 24‑hour fitness facilities |
| Meeting & event space | Multiple rooms and ballrooms across several floors, significant Midtown event capacity | Conference space ~3,600 sq ft and 6 meeting rooms |
| Family & kids | All ages welcome; children's programs (Peninsula Academy / Camp Peninsula) and no pool age restriction | All ages welcome; children stay free when occupying parent/guardian room using existing bedding |
| Nearby highlights | Fifth Avenue shopping, Central Park, Broadway and flagship stores | Madison Square Park, Flatiron Building, Empire State Building — short walks |
The Peninsula sits on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street, placing you within easy walking distance of Midtown shopping, museums and Central Park.
Choose The Peninsula for immediate Midtown access and Fifth Avenue shopping.
The Ritz‑Carlton New York, NoMad is in the NoMad/Flatiron area, close to Madison Square Park and the Empire State Building.
Choose Ritz‑Carlton NoMad for downtown neighborhoods, parkside strolls and Flatiron access.
Rooms at The Peninsula follow a refined, classic design across nine room types and multiple suites in a landmark building.
The Peninsula suits travelers who want classic, formally styled rooms in a landmark building.
The Ritz‑Carlton NoMad offers a broad list of room types and club rooms with Club Lounge access in a modern tower format.
Ritz‑Carlton NoMad is a good fit if you prefer contemporary rooms and Club Lounge benefits.
The Peninsula emphasizes refined American dining and classic hotel venues, including a famed afternoon tea and rooftop bar.
Peninsula is for travelers seeking classic Midtown dining experiences and a formal afternoon tea option.
Ritz‑Carlton NoMad provides hotel dining with Mediterranean influence and 24‑hour room service.
Ritz‑Carlton NoMad suits guests who want modern hotel dining and convenient 24‑hour room service.
The Peninsula's notable amenity is a glass‑enclosed indoor pool on the upper floors, available to hotel guests.
If an indoor pool is important, The Peninsula is the clear choice.
The Ritz‑Carlton New York, NoMad lists strong wellness and fitness offerings but published details on a guest pool are not available.
Ritz‑Carlton NoMad focuses on modern spa and fitness; pool details are not published.
The Peninsula combines a Forbes‑rated spa, 24‑hour Technogym fitness center and bars including a rooftop terrace.
Peninsula balances a high‑rated spa and late‑night rooftop options in Midtown.
Ritz‑Carlton NoMad offers an on‑site full‑service spa and round‑the‑clock fitness facilities plus hotel bars and lounges.
Ritz‑Carlton NoMad is suited to travelers who want modern spa treatments and 24‑hour fitness in NoMad.

The Peninsula New York — immediate Fifth Avenue address and easy access to MoMA, Rockefeller Center and Central Park.

The Ritz‑Carlton New York, NoMad — contemporary tower, close to Flatiron, Madison Square Park and downtown dining.

The Peninsula New York — glass‑enclosed indoor pool on upper floors with guest access included.

The Ritz‑Carlton New York, NoMad — newer Ritz‑Carlton property with Club Room/Suite options and recognizable brand standards.
If you want Midtown landmarks, Fifth Avenue shopping and proximity to Central Park and major museums, choose The Peninsula. For a downtown, NoMad‑Flatiron base, choose the Ritz‑Carlton NoMad.
The Peninsula New York has a glass‑enclosed indoor pool on the upper floors. Pool details for The Ritz‑Carlton New York, NoMad are not published.
Both hotels welcome guests of all ages. The Peninsula specifically lists children's programs and allows children under 12 to stay free; the Ritz‑Carlton listing states children stay free when using existing bedding.
The Peninsula has Pen Top, a rooftop bar with terraces over Fifth Avenue (21+ on the terrace). Ritz‑Carlton NoMad offers bars and lounges but its rooftop/nightlife profile is more modern and neighborhood‑focused.
Explore how The Peninsula New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·