
The Peninsula New York
Best for travelers who want a traditional Fifth Avenue address, a Forbes-rated full-service spa, and access to an indoor pool on property.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Peninsula New York is a landmark Beaux-Arts Fifth Avenue hotel with a strong focus on spa facilities and a glass-enclosed indoor pool; this guide is for travelers who want classic Midtown heritage, a rooftop bar, and a full-service spa. Four Seasons Hotel New York is a high-rise Midtown luxury hotel known for large rooms and I.M. Pei–designed architecture; read on if you prioritize oversized suites and a globally recognized five-star brand.
Updated · about 0.3 km apart

Best for travelers who want a traditional Fifth Avenue address, a Forbes-rated full-service spa, and access to an indoor pool on property.

Best for guests who want very large suites, a prominent five-star brand, and a Midtown location with easy access to Central Park and Fifth Avenue shopping.
When The Peninsula New York wins: choose The Peninsula if you value a landmark Beaux-Arts building, a full-service Forbes-rated spa on the upper floors, a glass-enclosed indoor pool with complimentary guest access, and multiple on-site dining venues including a rooftop bar and a famed afternoon tea lounge.
When Four Seasons Hotel New York wins: choose Four Seasons if you want larger-than-average Midtown rooms and suites, a globally recognized five-star brand, and an address steps from Central Park and Fifth Avenue shopping with established meeting and event facilities.
Bottom line: both are Midtown luxury icons within a short walk of each other; pick The Peninsula for spa-and-pool-focused stays and classic Fifth Avenue character, or pick Four Seasons for very large rooms and the cachet of a flagship global luxury brand.
| Category | The Peninsula New York | Four Seasons Hotel New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Classic Fifth Avenue Beaux-Arts luxury with refined public rooms | Soaring modern luxury with large-suite proportions and landmark architecture |
| Location | 700 Fifth Avenue at 55th Street — on Fifth Avenue, close to shopping and Central Park | 57 E 57th Street — Midtown, steps from Fifth Avenue and Central Park |
| City | Manhattan, New York | |
| Size (rooms) | About 235 guest rooms across 23 floors | 368 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Buildings / architecture | 1905 Beaux-Arts landmark building (Gotham Hotel origin) | High-rise building with I.M. Pei association and modern proportions |
| Pools | Glass-enclosed indoor pool on upper floors (guest access included) | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Clement (main restaurant), Clement Bar, Gotham Lounge (Afternoon Tea), Pen Top rooftop bar | One on-site restaurant (The Garden Restaurant) and a bar/lounge; 24-hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | The Peninsula Spa (Forbes Five-Star) on upper floors with 11 treatment rooms, saunas, steam rooms | Not published |
| Family-friendly | Welcomes children of all ages; seasonal kids programs and family pool access | Family-friendly; one child 17 or younger stays free when using existing bedding |
| Event & meeting space | Multiple small-to-medium meeting rooms and several event venues, including Gramercy spaces and rooftop terraces | Conference center and meeting rooms with about 12,120 sq ft (1,126 sq m) of meeting space |
The Peninsula sits at 700 Fifth Avenue at 55th Street on the corner of Fifth Avenue, a short walk to Central Park and flagship shops.
Pick The Peninsula for a classic Fifth Avenue address and immediate access to Midtown shopping and museums.
Four Seasons Hotel New York is on E 57th Street, a short walk to Central Park and Fifth Avenue shopping.
Pick Four Seasons for a central Midtown base with quick access to Central Park and Fifth Avenue.
The Peninsula offers roughly 235 rooms in a historic Beaux-Arts building with a range of room and suite categories.
Choose The Peninsula for classic hotel rooms in a landmark building with a range of suite options.
Four Seasons lists 368 individually decorated guestrooms and multiple junior and multi-bedroom suites.
Choose Four Seasons for larger rooms and a wide selection of suite layouts, including multi-bedroom options.
The Peninsula has multiple on-site venues from a main restaurant to a rooftop bar and a famous Afternoon Tea lounge.
The Peninsula is the better choice if you want multiple on-site dining experiences without leaving the hotel.
Four Seasons provides The Garden Restaurant for local cuisine plus bar/lounge service and 24-hour room service.
Four Seasons suits guests who prefer in-room dining and a single, well-regarded on-site restaurant.
The Peninsula’s glass-enclosed indoor pool and sun terrace are situated on the upper floors and open daily.
If an on-site indoor pool and terrace matter, The Peninsula provides explicit guest access and poolside dining.
Four Seasons supplier listing does not publish an on-site pool.
Pool facilities are not published for Four Seasons in the supplied listing; confirm with the property if a pool is a deciding factor.
The Peninsula Spa is a major draw, with 11 treatment rooms, saunas, steam rooms, and specialized treatments.
The Peninsula is the stronger pick for guests focused on spa treatments and a packaged wellness experience.
Four Seasons lists 24-hour fitness facilities and concierge services; supplier info emphasizes meetings and location.
Choose Four Seasons when fitness and large-suite accommodations matter more than an in-house spa program as described in the supplier listing.

The Peninsula — Forbes-rated Peninsula Spa with dedicated treatment rooms, saunas, steam rooms, and pool access.

Four Seasons — numerous junior, park-view, and multi-bedroom suites, including two-bedroom Manhattan suites.

The Peninsula — located directly on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street for immediate access to flagship shopping.

Four Seasons — a globally recognized five-star brand with 368 individually decorated guestrooms and meeting facilities.
Both are in Midtown with short walks to Central Park; Four Seasons is a short walk from the park and The Peninsula is about four blocks south of Central Park.
The Peninsula publishes a glass-enclosed indoor pool with guest access. The Four Seasons supplier listing does not publish an on-site pool; check with the property for current amenities.
No. Both hotels welcome guests of all ages.
Four Seasons lists larger suite configurations (including multi-bedroom suites) that may suit families needing separate rooms; The Peninsula offers family-friendly programs, a family-friendly pool access policy, and children's activities.
Explore how The Peninsula New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·