
The Peninsula New York
Best for travelers who prioritize a compact, service-focused Midtown stay with a top-rated spa and a single convenient Midtown address on Fifth Avenue.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Peninsula New York is a refined, relatively intimate Fifth Avenue luxury hotel with a high-end spa and indoor pool; read this if you want a compact Midtown base with notable wellness amenities. Lotte New York Palace is a large, landmark Madison Avenue hotel in a palace setting; read this if you want a grand, family-friendly Midtown property with many room and event options.
Updated · about 0.4 km apart

Best for travelers who prioritize a compact, service-focused Midtown stay with a top-rated spa and a single convenient Midtown address on Fifth Avenue.

Best for travelers who want a grand, landmark hotel with many room types and large event spaces in a classic Midtown 'palace' setting.
When The Peninsula New York wins: choose The Peninsula if you want a smaller, design-conscious luxury hotel on Fifth Avenue with a highly rated full-service spa, an indoor pool included for guests, and a concentrated set of dining and bar options.
When Lotte New York Palace wins: choose Lotte Palace if you need a large hotel with a wide selection of room and suite configurations, extensive meeting and event space, and a recognizable Madison Avenue landmark address convenient to Rockefeller Center and Midtown sightseeing.
Bottom line: both are Midtown luxury landmarks; pick The Peninsula for a more intimate, wellness-forward stay on Fifth Avenue, and pick Lotte New York Palace for scale, variety of room/meeting choices, and the classic 'palace' setting.
| Category | The Peninsula New York | Lotte New York Palace |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Refined, intimate Fifth Avenue luxury | Large, landmark Midtown 'palace' hotel |
| Location | 700 Fifth Avenue at 55th Street — on Fifth Avenue near MoMA and Rockefeller Center | 455 Madison Ave — Midtown, steps from 5th Avenue and Rockefeller Center |
| Size (rooms) | 235 guest rooms | 909 guestrooms |
| Historic status / building | 1905 Beaux-Arts building; NYC landmark | Large landmark Midtown hotel (palace setting) |
| Pools | Glass‑enclosed indoor pool on upper floors; complimentary for hotel guests | Wheelchair-accessible pool listed (details on indoor/outdoor not specified) |
| Restaurants & bars | Clement, Clement Bar, Gotham Lounge (Afternoon Tea), Pen Top rooftop bar | Gold Room restaurant; on-site coffee shop/cafe; 1 bar/lounge (room service when available) |
| Spa & wellness | The Peninsula Spa — Forbes Five-Star, 11 treatment rooms, saunas/steam rooms, fitness center open 24 hours | Full-service spa on site, health club and steam room |
| Event & meeting space | Multiple smaller meeting rooms and ballrooms (Gramercy, Chelsea, etc.); several boutique event spaces | Conference center and extensive meeting rooms; ballroom and banquet facilities |
| Family policy | All ages welcome; kids programs (Peninsula Academy / Camp Peninsula); children under 12 stay free | Family-friendly; offers babysitting/childcare (surcharge) |
| Typical guest access & fees | Complimentary Wi‑Fi for guests; pool and fitness included for guests; no resort fee | Wired & wireless internet available for a surcharge; breakfast available for a fee |
| Nearest major sights | Directly on Fifth Avenue; very near MoMA, St. Patrick's, Rockefeller Center, Central Park | |
The Peninsula sits at 700 Fifth Avenue at 55th Street, placing you directly on Fifth Avenue within easy walking distance of MoMA, Rockefeller Center and Central Park.
Choose The Peninsula for a true Fifth Avenue address and immediate Midtown shopping and museum access.
Lotte New York Palace sits on Madison Avenue and positions you in the heart of Midtown, a short walk to Fifth Avenue, Rockefeller Center and many Midtown attractions.
Choose Lotte Palace if you want a central Midtown location in a large, recognizable hotel building near the same Midtown sights.
The Peninsula offers a compact set of room and suite types focused on refined design and consistent service (about 235 rooms).
The Peninsula’s smaller room inventory gives a consistent, boutique-style stay in a landmark building.
Lotte New York Palace offers a very wide range of room types and many suites — practical if you need specific configurations or larger multi-room suites.
Lotte Palace is better if you need many room configuration choices, including large family and multi-bedroom suites.
The Peninsula keeps dining focused: Clement restaurant, Clement Bar, Gotham Lounge for Afternoon Tea, and the Pen Top rooftop bar.
The Peninsula offers a compact set of distinctive outlets for a consistent dining and bar experience.
Lotte Palace provides full-house service with at least one main restaurant (Gold Room), a coffee shop/cafe and a bar/lounge — plus room service at limited hours.
Lotte fits travelers who want classic hotel dining service and convenience across many guest needs.
The Peninsula’s signature amenity is its glass-enclosed indoor pool on the upper floors with sun terrace and complimentary guest access.
If an indoor pool with terrace access and included guest access matters, The Peninsula is clear-cut.
Lotte lists a pool (wheelchair-accessible) and health-club facilities, but the supplier listing does not fully specify indoor/outdoor status.
Lotte provides spa and fitness facilities and a listed pool, but pool specifics are less clearly published than The Peninsula’s.
Wellness at The Peninsula centers on The Peninsula Spa (Forbes Five‑Star) plus a 24-hour fitness center and curated spa programming.
The Peninsula emphasizes high-end spa services as a primary part of the guest experience.
Lotte offers full-service spa treatments and a health club, alongside broader hotel services such as babysitting and extensive event support.
Lotte provides comprehensive hotel services and wellness options but positions them within a larger, multi-purpose hotel operation.

The Peninsula — a Forbes-rated full-service spa with 11 treatment rooms and dedicated wellness facilities.

Lotte New York Palace — a very large room inventory including Palace and Towers suites and multi-bedroom configurations.

The Peninsula — located directly on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street, steps from flagship stores and museums.

Lotte New York Palace — conference center, ballroom and extensive meeting rooms suitable for larger groups.
The Peninsula is directly on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street and is the closer choice for flagship stores and immediate shopping access.
The Peninsula is known for The Peninsula Spa (Forbes Five‑Star) with a detailed published facility list; Lotte has a full-service spa but The Peninsula’s spa details and rating are more prominently published.
Yes — Lotte is described as family-friendly and lists babysitting/childcare (surcharge). The supplier listing shows family room types and large suites.
The Peninsula expressly includes complimentary access to its glass‑enclosed indoor pool for hotel guests. Lotte lists a wheelchair‑accessible pool, but the supplier listing does not publish full guest-access details.
Explore how The Peninsula New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·